← Back to issue
CBS NEWS

Justice Department asks a DC grand jury to indict Cassidy Hutchinson for lying to Congress in her 2022 Jan. 6 testimony

Political Guyentist · October 9, 20263 min read

CBS NEWS

The Civil Rights Division is running the case instead of the DC U.S. Attorney's Office, an unusual choice that CBS says has not been explained.

The case. Justice Department prosecutors are presenting evidence to a grand jury in Washington, D.C. (a panel of citizens that decides whether there is enough evidence to bring charges). The question is whether Cassidy Hutchinson, a former aide to White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows, lied to the House Jan. 6 committee in June 2022. A DOJ spokesperson said the department "does not confirm or deny the existence of investigations, or the lack thereof."

The testimony. CBS reports it is unclear which of her answers prosecutors are examining. Her best-known claim, that Trump lunged at the steering wheel of his SUV on Jan. 6, 2021, was secondhand, and other witnesses have disputed it.

What next. Prosecutors plan to bring more evidence and witnesses before the grand jury later in October 2026, Punchbowl News reported.

How three witnesses' accounts cut against the steering-wheel storyThe SUV driver told the committee in a Nov. 7, 2022 interview that Trump never grabbed the wheel and never lunged into the front…3 details
  • The SUV driver told the committee in a Nov. 7, 2022 interview that Trump never grabbed the wheel and never lunged into the front seat.
  • Ornato said in his Nov. 29, 2022 interview that he first heard the story from her public testimony and did not believe he had told it to her.
  • Robert Engel, head of Trump's Secret Service detail, did not recall Trump reaching for him or being in the room when Ornato spoke to Hutchinson.

What we’re less sure of2 of 7 claims

Red take

A grand jury should test Cassidy Hutchinson's sworn story, because her own source disowns it. Hutchinson, a former aide to Trump's chief of staff, said aide Tony Ornato told her Trump lunged at the wheel. Ornato told the committee on Nov. 29, 2022 that he first heard it from her public testimony. If that goes untested, any witness can put an invented scene about a president into the record at no cost.

Blue take

Prosecuting Cassidy Hutchinson, a former aide to Trump's chief of staff, turns a memory dispute into a crime. Tony Ornato, the aide she named, said only that he "did not believe he had told it to her", which is doubt, not the knowing lie the law requires. The Civil Rights Division runs the case, a choice CBS says has not been explained. Every aide asked to testify about a president now learns that honest memory can bring an indictment.